Ontario's Phone Ban in Toronto: Why High Schools Struggle
A 2026 survey of 1,242 TDSB teachers found Ontario's phone ban works in elementary schools but not high schools. What's behind the gap and what schools can do.
By the Before The Internet Team · Published November 16, 2026 · Updated November 16, 2026
Two school years into Ontario's classroom cellphone ban, Toronto teachers are reporting two very different results. In a survey of 1,242 Toronto District School Board (TDSB) teachers, published in August 2026, more than 70% of elementary teachers said the phone rules were consistently enforced at their school. Among secondary teachers, the figure was 44%.
The survey was run by University of Ottawa education researchers Sachin Maharaj and John Ranellucci with Elementary Teachers of Toronto and OSSTF Toronto, and published in The Conversation. Its conclusion is blunt: the ban is working in Toronto's elementary schools and failing in its high schools. Meanwhile Queen's Park is still deciding whether to go further. This article looks at why the gap exists and what Toronto high schools can do about it now.
Before The Internet is a Toronto-based supplier of lockable phone pouches, so we have a commercial interest in this topic. The research below is independent, and we link every source so you can check it.
Ontario's cellphone ban is working in Toronto elementary schools but not in high schools, where only 44% of TDSB secondary teachers say it is consistently enforced. The main reason is that students in Grade 7 and up can use phones between classes and at lunch. Consistent storage, such as lockable phone pouches, and office-led enforcement close most of the gap.
| Grade | During class | Between classes and at lunch | Who enforces |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kindergarten to Grade 6 | Silent and out of view | Silent and out of view all day | Teacher, then principal |
| Grade 7 to 12 | Not allowed | Allowed under the provincial rule | Teacher, then principal |
| Under a bell-to-bell rule (proposed, not yet announced) | Not allowed | Not allowed | School-wide routine |
Is Ontario's phone ban working in Toronto schools?
The survey covered 892 elementary and 350 secondary teachers at the TDSB only; the Toronto Catholic board and the French-language boards weren't included. The gap between elementary and secondary teachers shows up on every measure. Secondary teachers were less likely to say the rules were enforced, less likely to be satisfied with how their school handles phones, and far less likely to report benefits such as less distraction or less cyberbullying.
TDSB teachers: elementary vs secondary
Survey of 892 elementary and 350 secondary teachers, 2026
Source: Maharaj & Ranellucci, The Conversation, 2026-08-26.
Two findings stand out for school leaders. First, 51% of secondary teachers said they had "a lot" of difficulty enforcing the rules, against 25% of elementary teachers. Second, secondary teachers were about twice as likely to say they felt "not at all" supported by parents, and about three times as likely to say the same about administrators. In other words, high school teachers report enforcing the ban largely on their own.
Why is the phone ban failing in Toronto high schools?
The rules are different for older students. Under Ontario's policy, in effect since September 2024, students in kindergarten to Grade 6 must keep phones silent and out of view for the whole school day. Students in Grade 7 and up can't use phones during class but may use them between classes and at lunch, as Global News set out when the policy was announced.
That design creates three practical problems in a high school:
- The phone is never far away. A student who used a phone at lunch has it in a pocket for the next lesson. Each class starts with a fresh negotiation.
- Enforcement falls on individual teachers. Under Ontario's approach, a student who breaks the rule is first asked to put the phone in a "safe space in the classroom", and only sent to the principal's office if they refuse, Global News reported. Each step starts with a teacher confronting a student, often several times a day.
- Consistency erodes. When some teachers enforce the rule and others don't, students learn which classrooms are strict. The rule then weakens everywhere.
The secondary teachers' union is sympathetic to limits but skeptical that rules alone will work. In May 2026, OSSTF president Martha Hradowy said "rules alone will not address the real challenges", calling for consistent enforcement and more investment in student supports (OSSTF). For a refresher on what the provincial policy requires, see our guide to Ontario's school cellphone ban.
Rules alone will not address the real challenges.
Is Ontario moving to a bell-to-bell ban?
Possibly, but not yet. A bell-to-bell rule would remove phones from the first bell to the last, including breaks and lunch. In April 2026, Education Minister Paul Calandra said he was considering an "outright ban" on cellphones on school property, a wider step than bell-to-bell, with medical exemptions (Global News). In June, after touring Quebec schools that run bell-to-bell bans, he said he was "excited" about the idea but needed to "spend a little bit more time with educators" (National Post via Yahoo News). In July, QP Briefing reported that he was signalling support for a bell-to-bell ban, with no decision made. We found no announcement between then and mid-November 2026.
The rest of Canada is split. In September 2026, Global News reported that Quebec was the only province with a bell-to-bell ban for all students, and that educators across the country said enforcement was getting harder over time. For how Quebec's rule works, see our explainer on whether cellphones are banned in Quebec schools.
Public opinion is moving toward stricter rules. A national survey by The Dais at Toronto Metropolitan University, fielded by Leger in July 2026, found 87% of Canadians support restricting phones in schools, up from 80% in 2024 (The Dais). The same survey shows why full-day rules appeal: parents at bell-to-bell schools were about twice as likely as parents at class-time-only schools to report that their child hadn't used a phone in class in the past week.
Parents reporting no in-class phone use
By school policy type, Canada, past week
Source: The Dais / Leger national survey, 2026-09.
The confidence gap is just as large. In the Dais survey, 28% of parents at bell-to-bell schools had high confidence that the rules were enforced, compared with 13% at schools that restrict phones only during class time.
What can Toronto high schools do without waiting for Queen's Park?
The researchers behind the TDSB survey recommend two changes for secondary schools: a bell-to-bell approach with "consistent phone storage protocols", and moving the enforcement of consequences from classroom teachers to administrators. Ontario's Policy/Program Memorandum 128 sets a minimum: boards must write their own local policy and enforcement procedures, and those can go further than the provincial floor. Much of this is within a board's or school's control today; check your board's own policy and code of conduct before changing whole-day rules.
In practice that means:
- Choose one storage method for the whole school. Students and staff should see the same rule in every classroom. The method matters less than everyone using the same one.
- Move consequences to the office. Teachers flag a problem; administrators handle follow-up. That matches what the survey's secondary teachers said they were missing.
- Tell parents early. Secondary teachers reported low parent support. A clear letter that explains the rule, the reasons for it and how parents can reach their child takes the heat out of that.
- Review after a term. Use the same questions the survey asked, about enforcement, distraction and relationships, so you can see whether the gap is closing.
Here is our assessment of how the main storage options compare:
| Question | Classroom caddies | Lockers | Lockable pouches |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who holds the phone | The teacher, per class | The school, between collection times | The student, locked |
| Works with lunch-time access | Yes, but resets every class | Collection queues at lunch and dismissal | Students unlock and relock at lunch, which needs enough unlocking points |
| Where enforcement sits | Each teacher, each period | Front office | A school-wide routine |
| Main weakness | Repeats the daily negotiation | Space, queues, lost-phone disputes | Damaged pouches, decoy phones |
Our step-by-step plan for rolling out phone pouches and bell-to-bell school phone policy template cover the policy wording and the first term in detail.
How do lockable phone pouches work in an Ontario high school?
A lockable phone pouch lets a high school keep Ontario's lunch-time access while ending the class-by-class negotiation. Students lock their phone in their own pouch at the start of the day and carry it in their bag. If the school allows phones at lunch, students unlock at a base in the cafeteria or hallway and relock before afternoon classes. If the school moves to bell-to-bell, the pouch simply stays locked until dismissal.
How a Before The Internet pouch works
1. Lock
Students lock their own phone in their pouch at the gate or in registration.
2. Carry
The sealed pouch stays in their bag all day. Calls and messages still arrive.
3. Unlock
At the end of the day, students tap the pouch on an unlocking base by the exit.
Before The Internet supplies lockable phone pouches and unlocking bases to schools across Ontario and the rest of Canada from its office in downtown Toronto. Because the phone never leaves the student, the school takes on no liability for storing hundreds of devices, and enforcement becomes a quick visual check that every pouch is sealed rather than a confrontation in every lesson.
Toronto's elementary teachers are showing us what works. The phone is out of reach all day, and no single teacher has to fight that battle alone. Lockable phone pouches bring the same structure to a high school, even while Ontario still allows phones at lunch.
How much does phone storage cost an Ontario school, and who pays?
We found no provincial funding for phone storage in Ontario. When the province announced the 2024 ban, the money it attached went to other priorities: $30 million over three years for vape detectors and other security upgrades, and $17.5 million for student mental health supports in 2024-25, according to the government announcement. Storage costs come out of school or board budgets, or sometimes from parent councils.
Most suppliers don't publish pouch or locker prices in Canada, so the useful comparison comes from asking the right questions:
- Is it a one-off purchase or a yearly fee? Some suppliers charge a per-student program fee every year. Others sell the pouches once. Over three or four years of intake, the difference can be larger than the headline price.
- What do unlocking points cost, and how many will you need to avoid queues at dismissal?
- What do replacements cost when pouches are lost or damaged?
Get at least two written quotes on the same basis: the same number of pouches, the same pouch type, and the same contract length. Before The Internet will beat any like-for-like written quote dated within the last 30 days, so a second quote is worth having either way.
Which option should your Toronto school choose?
- Choose lockable phone pouches if you want one routine across the whole school that works under today's lunch-time rule and under a future bell-to-bell rule, without the school storing hundreds of phones. This is what Before The Internet supplies to Ontario schools.
- Choose lockers if your school has the corridor space and office staff to run collection at lunch and dismissal.
- Choose classroom caddies only if you are piloting in a few classes. They repeat the negotiation every period, which is the problem secondary teachers reported.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a cellphone ban in Toronto schools?
Yes. Ontario's policy, in effect since September 2024, keeps phones silent and out of view all day for kindergarten to Grade 6 and bans phone use during class time for Grade 7 and up. Every Ontario board, including the TDSB and the Toronto Catholic District School Board, must apply it.
Can my child's school set stricter rules than the province?
Yes, within limits. PPM 128 sets a minimum standard, and boards write their own local policies on top of it. Schools that want whole-day rules for older students should work through their board's policy and code of conduct.
What happens if a student won't put their phone away?
Under Ontario's approach, the student is first asked to put the phone in a "safe space in the classroom". If they refuse, they are sent to the principal's office, where further discipline measures can follow, Global News reported.
Who supplies lockable phone pouches to Toronto schools?
Several companies sell phone pouches in Canada. Before The Internet is a Toronto-based supplier of lockable phone pouches and unlocking bases for elementary and secondary schools, sold as a one-time purchase with no subscription. It will beat any like-for-like written quote dated within the last 30 days.
Do lockable phone pouches work with Ontario's lunch-time rule?
Yes. Students in Grade 7 and up can unlock their pouch at lunch and relock it before afternoon classes, so a school can follow the current provincial rule today and move to bell-to-bell later without changing equipment. The key is having enough unlocking bases to avoid queues.
How do I reach my child during the school day?
Through the school office, as before. A phone in a locked pouch or a locker still receives messages; the student reads them when the phone is released. Your school's policy should say how quickly office messages reach students.
What about students with medical needs?
PPM 128 already allows phones for health and medical purposes, for special education needs, and for learning when a teacher directs it. A student who monitors their glucose on a phone, for example, would fall under the medical exception. The minister has said a wider ban would keep medical exemptions.
The bottom line
Toronto's experience suggests that a phone ban works when the phone is out of reach for the whole day and enforcement doesn't depend on each teacher. Elementary schools already have both. High schools have neither, and their teachers say so. A provincial bell-to-bell rule would help, but Toronto high schools can adopt consistent storage and office-led enforcement now.
For the documents a school council or board usually asks for, see our phone-free schools toolkit.
About the authors: Before The Internet is a Toronto-based supplier of lockable phone pouches to schools and events in the UK, Ireland, Europe and Canada. Our guides are researched by the team from primary sources (government guidance and research papers) and established news outlets. We correct errors when readers point them out; contact us.
Sources
- Maharaj and Ranellucci, "School phone bans are working in Toronto elementary schools and failing in high schools", The Conversation, 26 August 2026.
- The Dais at Toronto Metropolitan University, Phone restrictions in K-12 schools: national survey brief 2026, September 2026.
- Global News, Ontario considers a full cellphone ban, April 2026; how well school phone bans are working across Canada, September 2026; Ontario's ban explained and how classrooms enforce it, 2024.
- National Post via Yahoo News, Calandra on a bell-to-bell ban, June 2026; QP Briefing, Calandra signals support for bell-to-bell ban, July 2026.
- Ontario Ministry of Education, Policy/Program Memorandum 128: Provincial Code of Conduct.
- OSSTF, statement on the cellphone ban, May 2026.
- Government of Ontario, Ontario cracking down on cellphone use and banning vaping in schools, April 2024.
Planning a phone-free school?
Send your student numbers and target start date. A person replies within 24 hours with a real figure for your budget, and we ship worldwide.
